|
|
Post by Lance on Jul 24, 2005 5:38:32 GMT -5
This is up a day early, but that doesn't really matter because everyone sent theirs in except for Dan. Voting is simple, clearly state reasons for why you choose a certain person. Don't just write one line, at least a paragraph to show you actually have reasons behind it. HBK vs Lance Subject: Favourite Wrestler HBK  vs Lance  TT vs D619S Subject: RAW! Doin It 619 Style  vs TajiriTaruntula  JWW vs Dan vs TPF Subject: Smackdown Jasonwestwwe  vs The French Phenom  Rules: 1. No use of PSDs. 2. No use of tutorials. 3. All are best of 3 votes. 4. Due by July 25th. Begin voting  |
|
|
|
Post by Lance on Jul 24, 2005 5:53:33 GMT -5
My voting (I posted again so it doesn't get confused with all the stuff up there, I will remove a post from my count for the extra post):
D619S vs TT
D619S: The cutting is the main good part of the banner, it looks great. The background looks alright and needs work, but is different, and you can tell you put in effort. The pics are well placed, but I think the Crossface looks too small. Apart from that it is great.
TT: There isn't really much to say. From what I can see, there isn't much to the background except for the RAW logo and a shot of the crowd. Too much white. The font looks pretty bad, you have used it on almost all your banners so far and it just doesn't suit wrestling much. The cutting isn't very good, RVD looks like he has a hole in the back of his head, and the others have little tufts of black around them. Needs alot of work.
Vote: Doin It 619 Style
It just looks like D619S actually put alot of effort in to his, meanwhile TT just slapped his together in 5 minutes.
TPF vs JWW
JWW: I like the overall layout of yours, it just seems to all fit in place. Rey-Rey is badly sized thought in his stance pic. The cutting is mostly done well on the Rey pic. But the Eddie pic isnt even cut at all... the handshake pic has been cut good but there is bits left on the outside. The text is alright and could be done better, but it looks good. I don't really enjoy the jagged line in between Rey and Eddie though.
TFP:The cutting on the picture is great, minus if you look closely in some sections, you can see some left over cutting bits. The Smackdown logo looks good, but I don't like how there is two WWE logos. The red text doesn't match well, maybe blue would do better. Also the text is hard to make out against the pic where it says "Home of". Good work
Vote: The French Phenom
It just overall looks better, through the layout and cutting. JWW's is really good, but there is some small stuff needing fixing, like the cutting missed out and things like that.
|
|
Conti
Full Member
Wheres Fifi???
Posts: 317
|
Post by Conti on Jul 24, 2005 6:45:00 GMT -5
HBK: Great work I'm loving the Main Image. The Background Sweet chin Music really goes well with the whole Scheme. The Cut out has been done well and the Main text looks Great but the lowtext I'm not really liking maybe a diffrent Font. OverallGreat Job
Lance: Wow..Cutting is absolutley wickid with ur Main Pic of London and the Pic is Sick as. I like the Tape roll Idea and Text Is Looks wickid and Totaly goes with the Tape roll. I'm not Sure about the Background but other Wise Great Job overall.
Vote: Lance
D619: I'm Not liking the Background of ur Banner..Its doesn't Match the Pics really. The Cutting out is Nice for all Pics but for Next the time Background Use Maybe somethink bit More Daker. The Raw Logo been Blend into the Background looks good aswell. Overall Good Job
Tajiri: The Cutting out isn't too Shabby needs some work. The Background is quite plain. But I like the Idea of the Crowd would of been Better if we saw more of it.
The Text is Alright but I would like to seen a Diffrent type but Overall Ok job
Vote: D619
|
|
|
|
Post by HBK on Jul 24, 2005 8:13:49 GMT -5
DI619S: I'm not really sure what to say about this banner. The background is kinda wierd. No, wait, scratch that, its VERY wierd. The RAW logo is hard to spot. The pictures are all right but dont match the background. The WWE logo is really good though.
TT: The font isnt good. USE A DIFFERENT FONT!! The cutting out isnt spectacular either. The RAW logo is well placed in this banner and it is easy visible. I also like the crowd. Too much white though.
Vote: I really cannot vote on this. I do not especially like either of them.
TFP: No critisicm for this at all except possibly for the double WWE logo. I dont like them and also the Smackdown! logo is slightly blurry. The only other thing is the home is the hard to read. Otherwise, good work!
JWW: The fonts are bad. The pics are cut off halfway down (HOW MANY TIMES MUST I SAY THIS!!) the cutting isnt too flash. There is no border and also the American flag looks out of place as well as the jagged line though I can see what you were trying to do.
Vote: The French Phenom
|
|
|
|
Post by tajiritarantula on Jul 24, 2005 8:21:41 GMT -5
HBK vs LANCE
HBK: I like this banner, but there's just something about it that doesn't seem right, maybe it's too bright.
Background: 4/10
Text: 8/10
Pictures: 6/10
Layout: 8/10
Overall: 7/10
TOTAL SCORE: 35
LANCE: This is cool, I like the way it is in frames.
Background: 8.5/10
Text: 9/10
Pictures: 6/10
Layout: 9.5/10
Overall: 8/10
TOTAL SCORE: 41
FRENCH PHENOM vs JASONWESTWWE
JASONWESTWWE: This isn't too bad, it just appears a bit too unprofessional.
Background: 2/10
Text: 3/10
Pictures: 5/10
Layout: 3.5/10
Overall: 3.5/10
TOTAL SCORE: 17
FRENCH PHENOM: For a paint job, this is great. I like this.
Background: 3/10
Text: 6.5/10
Pictures: 8.5/10
Layout: 7/10
Overall: 7/10
TOTAL SCORE: 32
SO MY VOTES GO TO:
LANCE
AND
FRENCH PHENOM
|
|
|
|
Post by jasonwestwwe on Jul 25, 2005 0:52:29 GMT -5
HBK Vs Lance:
HBK: I quite like this and banner is pretty good too. I like the background and it looks like you used the glowing effect which looks pretty cool! And the pictures are well placed too! So i'll give you 7.5/10
Lance: This is pretty Good too the cutting is perfect and the background is awesome but there is somthing i dont like about mini pictures and the text is awesome too! So this is going to be hard but i'll give you a 8/10
So my vote goes to LANCE
D619 VS TT
D619: This is pretty good i like the cutting and all the picutures but i dont like the background.... So i'll give you a 6.5/10
TT: I dont really like this i think that the cutting is pretty bad and the picutres arnt really good but i like the background and the text so i give you 5/10
So my vote goes to D619
|
|
